{ "schema_version": "uw.editorial_geo.v1", "representation_profile": "lossless_source_sections", "local_stage_only": true, "catalog_id": "DEP-20-N07", "article_index": "DEP-20-N07", "language": "en", "headline": "Buddhism: craving, clarity, and care without a test of faith", "description": "Buddhism: craving, clarity, and care without a test of faith", "short_answer": "Someone may recognize their distressing sense of “I want more” in the Buddhist word *taṇhā*. That resemblance neither identifies the cause of their substance use nor establishes a diagnosis. Someone else may choose a commitment to sobriety as an expression of care. A third person may find company in a Buddhist community while realizing that fear of withdrawal cannot be settled by talking to a teacher alone. Tradition can offer meaning and relationships, while physical risk and the kind of help required still need their own assessment.\n\nThere is no single Buddhist answer, binding across all schools, to every question about alcohol, prescribed medicines, and substance use treatment. We will distinguish an early Pali text, rules at one British monastery, Plum Village’s ethical training, and a Tibetan FPMT explanation of lay vows. These are named sources with different audiences, not stages in a universal recovery program. A separate clinical source helps establish what mindfulness research can and cannot promise.\n\nIf **poisoning is suspected** from a substance or medicine, **contact your local emergency medical service immediately, even before symptoms appear**. Symptoms can be delayed, as the [NHS poisoning page](https://www.nhs.uk/conditions/Poisoning/) explains. **New sudden confusion, by itself**, also calls for immediate local emergency medical contact: do not wait for it to seem “severe” or for another sign to develop. The [NHS confusion page](https://www.nhs.uk/symptoms/confusion/) identifies sudden onset as urgent. An emergency cannot wait for a meditation session, a discussion of vows, or an admission of substance use.", "short_answer_source": { "kind": "explicit_about_h2", "role": "lead", "start_utf16": 498, "end_utf16": 2150, "sha256_utf8": "d128ca5d20bea9dcacb8eae51c3ea9f3ec44070e5ffce2afa345d33813d86ba1" }, "headline_source": { "role": "h1_heading", "start_utf16": 2, "end_utf16": 62, "sha256_utf8": "c7545bfaeef9f8d2fd349f082d2355b6d10d522128ea6fed9053bcb3af6b2a84" }, "entities": [], "questions": [ { "q": "What this article is about", "a": "Someone may recognize their distressing sense of “I want more” in the Buddhist word *taṇhā*. That resemblance neither identifies the cause of their substance use nor establishes a diagnosis. Someone else may choose a commitment to sobriety as an expression of care. A third person may find company in a Buddhist community while realizing that fear of withdrawal cannot be settled by talking to a teacher alone. Tradition can offer meaning and relationships, while physical risk and the kind of help required still need their own assessment.\n\nThere is no single Buddhist answer, binding across all schools, to every question about alcohol, prescribed medicines, and substance use treatment. We will distinguish an early Pali text, rules at one British monastery, Plum Village’s ethical training, and a Tibetan FPMT explanation of lay vows. These are named sources with different audiences, not stages in a universal recovery program. A separate clinical source helps establish what mindfulness research can and cannot promise.\n\nIf **poisoning is suspected** from a substance or medicine, **contact your local emergency medical service immediately, even before symptoms appear**. Symptoms can be delayed, as the [NHS poisoning page](https://www.nhs.uk/conditions/Poisoning/) explains. **New sudden confusion, by itself**, also calls for immediate local emergency medical contact: do not wait for it to seem “severe” or for another sign to develop. The [NHS confusion page](https://www.nhs.uk/symptoms/confusion/) identifies sudden onset as urgent. An emergency cannot wait for a meditation session, a discussion of vows, or an admission of substance use.", "source_spans": [ { "role": "h2_heading", "start_utf16": 470, "end_utf16": 496, "sha256_utf8": "a53bdb09d3d545eddde325393d7fae0fb8be199cef905ef433da14435f905db9" }, { "role": "h2_answer", "start_utf16": 498, "end_utf16": 2150, "sha256_utf8": "d128ca5d20bea9dcacb8eae51c3ea9f3ec44070e5ffce2afa345d33813d86ba1" } ], "block_ids": [ "p0005", "p0006", "p0007" ], "source_segment_index": 1 }, { "q": "I. First ask who is speaking, and to whom", "a": "It is easy to speak a religious text as though every present-day patient were its intended audience. A Pali verse uses imagery. A discourse describes a path in relation to *dukkha*, often rendered suffering or unsatisfactoriness. A monastery sets conditions for life within that institution. A community describes a practice for its members. None of these genres provides a diagnostic interview, an assessment of withdrawal risk, or a directory of services in every locality.\n\nThe [Pali *Dhammapada* text](https://dhammatalks.net/suttacentral/sc2016/sc/pi/dhp.html) used here is the 2005 World Tipiṭaka Roman-script edition prepared by the Dhamma Society Fund, accessed through a static archive. We did not verify the current live SuttaCentral interface. Its image of a river can invite reflection on the force of craving. It does not say every episode of substance use is produced by a spiritual flaw. Trauma, pain, another illness, lack of safety or resources, habit, physical adaptation, and other circumstances may overlap. A verse does not sort them out.\n\nRespecting that limit does not diminish the tradition. A person who chooses Buddhist language can explore whether it helps them speak with honesty and compassion. Someone who does not choose it remains just as entitled to seek medical and social care. Joining a community is not an entrance test for help. Even within a community, a teacher’s advice about practice and a clinician’s assessment of health answer different questions.", "source_spans": [ { "role": "h2_heading", "start_utf16": 2155, "end_utf16": 2196, "sha256_utf8": "c0996360da5f4d8a59101114b57eff03d8f855667816b17a7c0dc0decbef95e7" }, { "role": "h2_answer", "start_utf16": 2198, "end_utf16": 3690, "sha256_utf8": "e2cef6a4b3de22139cee14f46bee6a093ec5d6a3a8bfcf825308402d5770c3ff" } ], "block_ids": [ "p0009", "p0010", "p0011" ], "source_segment_index": 2 }, { "q": "II. A doctrinal craving is not a diagnosis", "a": "The second of the four truths in [SN 56:11, the *Dhammacakkappavattana Sutta*](https://www.dhammatalks.org/suttas/SN/SN56_11.html), names *taṇhā*. In the English translation by Ṭhānissaro Bhikkhu, based on a Thai edition of the Pali canon, this is described in relation to sensuality, becoming, and non-becoming. The discourse also rejects self-mortification and speaks of a middle way. It concerns a spiritual understanding of human experience; it does not classify alcohol, opioids, prescribed medicines, or an individual’s health risks.\n\nThe overlap between the English “craving” in a clinical setting and this Buddhist term can be useful for conversation but misleading as a conclusion. A clinician may use craving to describe one experience associated with a substance use disorder. *Taṇhā* in the discourse reaches beyond substances and beyond a wish for pleasure. Shared vocabulary does not show that the doctrine has explained this particular person’s condition. Someone who does not describe craving can still need help. Someone who does describe an intense wish has not thereby been diagnosed.\n\nThe same care is needed with “attachment.” Reflecting on clinging may help a person distinguish caring for someone from trying to govern their every choice. It does not make love for a child, mutual dependence during illness, or an agreed duty of care pathological. The useful question is less “Am I guilty of *taṇhā*?” than “What is happening, what is dangerous now, and what support fits?” Tradition may offer meaning for the first part of a person’s inquiry; facts, consent, and sometimes professional assessment are required for the rest.", "source_spans": [ { "role": "h2_heading", "start_utf16": 3695, "end_utf16": 3737, "sha256_utf8": "706c45ecca69c3bbb9faf643e34bb36b13a49a4775ce140a29266afe65d08627" }, { "role": "h2_answer", "start_utf16": 3739, "end_utf16": 5386, "sha256_utf8": "fe3db2ec992a430eacbadb4c1108c3e0d4d8e8911d8ff499a87cbf0b74eefc5b" } ], "block_ids": [ "p0013", "p0014", "p0015" ], "source_segment_index": 3 }, { "q": "III. The fifth precept is an ethic of clarity, not home withdrawal advice", "a": "[AN 8.39, the *Abhisandasutta*](https://dhammatalks.net/suttacentral/sc2016/sc/pi/an8.39.html), includes abstaining from intoxicants among actions by which a practitioner avoids causing harm. Its Pali language links intoxicants to heedlessness. For some Buddhists, sobriety therefore concerns attention, speech, and conduct toward others, not simply the status of a drink. It can make room for an honest conversation about damage done while intoxicated.\n\nAn ethical reason to abstain is nevertheless not a medical instruction to stop a substance abruptly at home. Where the body has adapted to alcohol or some medicines, a sudden change can be dangerous. A person who cannot safely take up a precept without clinical guidance has not failed a test of faith. Respect for the precept should include refusing to demand a risky demonstration of commitment. A person can discuss the precept and seek medical care at the same time, including before they have chosen a long-term goal.\n\nNor does the precept give others permission to demand a public diagnosis, count days of sobriety without consent, or call every prescribed medicine intoxication. In one setting a layperson takes a commitment voluntarily; in another a retreat has house rules; in another, a specialized ritual has its own context. None settles what a particular substance, prescription, health condition, or service means for this person. A chosen spiritual discipline needs to leave the path to safe treatment open.", "source_spans": [ { "role": "h2_heading", "start_utf16": 5391, "end_utf16": 5464, "sha256_utf8": "7626967c18e63f1adbb6cbd01b069c9e1b4aff126be06b76ef3229bf10f9d6b0" }, { "role": "h2_answer", "start_utf16": 5466, "end_utf16": 6943, "sha256_utf8": "7312c3cb07ba8e3e8792f4fa37d1a779f771e8a11db604ca8d09906091e3b3ba" } ], "block_ids": [ "p0017", "p0018", "p0019" ], "source_segment_index": 4 }, { "q": "IV. Theravāda: monastery conditions and lay life", "a": "At [Amaravati Buddhist Monastery in the United Kingdom](https://amaravati.org/visiting/frequently-asked-questions/), the eight precepts are presented as the standard for life **at that monastery** and include refraining from intoxicating drink and drugs. A visitor asking about a stay learns a local rule, not a decree for every Theravāda lay Buddhist. The same FAQ expects parents to supervise children who visit. A monastery schedule does not mean the institution can replace a doctor, safe housing, or an adult actually present to care for a child while another adult attends an appointment.\n\nIn [Ajahn Candasiri’s book of talks, *Simple Kindness*](https://cdn.amaravati.org/wp-content/uploads/2014/09/Simple_Kindness_-_Ajahn_Candasiri.pdf), five precepts used in lay life are distinguished from eight associated with monastic and retreat practice. When discussing intoxicants, she explicitly makes room for prescribed medicine. This is a meaningful distinction within a named Theravāda setting: avoiding recreational intoxication does not require treating all pain relief or medical treatment as a broken vow. Her words are not clinical approval of every drug and do not replace the prescriber’s advice.\n\nA layperson may choose a precept without adopting an entire monastery routine. A possible retreat guest can ask about rules, food, accommodation, medicines, and their own health needs beforehand. If care is needed, the question is who will actually provide it; good intentions do not create trained staff. The difference between inspiration and an available service matters most when a retreat seems an appealing substitute for an uncomfortable conversation with a clinician.", "source_spans": [ { "role": "h2_heading", "start_utf16": 6948, "end_utf16": 6996, "sha256_utf8": "005a23cbb6b3dca94da03cde28209b44a6d58d93f893394083641d742ae4bece" }, { "role": "h2_answer", "start_utf16": 6998, "end_utf16": 8682, "sha256_utf8": "ff40e52530524bc955a4ef14829fbd2a9e0c684b789f9b48c5c729f64d3b84dc" } ], "block_ids": [ "p0021", "p0022", "p0023" ], "source_segment_index": 5 }, { "q": "V. Plum Village: mindful consumption as a community choice", "a": "In [Plum Village’s Five Mindfulness Trainings](https://plumvillage.org/mindfulness/the-5-mindfulness-trainings), revised in 2022, the fifth extends attention from intoxicants to what nourishes or burdens one’s body and mind. It includes the community’s commitment to avoid alcohol and drugs and reflection on other kinds of consumption. This is the ethical language of a community in the lineage of Thich Nhat Hanh. It is neither the position of all Mahāyāna communities nor evidence that a clinical program has been tested.\n\nThe broader lens may help a person notice context. One person uses a substance after a demanding shift; another seeks relief from loneliness; another is pressed by company. Noticing a context does not establish a single cause or remove the need to assess the risks of the substance. A patient should not have to change every habit, screen, meal, relationship, and prescription simultaneously before being allowed a consultation. The training describes voluntary practice, not a readiness examination.\n\nIf this community interests someone, they can ask whether participation is possible without disclosing a diagnosis to a group, whether a vow is required, and who can answer questions in a language they understand. The answers depend on the specific center. A thoughtful text and a listed address do not demonstrate an open place, paid interpretation, licensed treatment, child care, or a protected route for health information. Spiritual opportunity can remain an opportunity without being misrepresented as a service already delivered.", "source_spans": [ { "role": "h2_heading", "start_utf16": 8687, "end_utf16": 8745, "sha256_utf8": "1d75a8afafa5947b8adbf06f3264e5f824ce8723dd3d21170d0a3d791d040d76" }, { "role": "h2_answer", "start_utf16": 8747, "end_utf16": 10311, "sha256_utf8": "ad05bee7d7589873bbc4e86622c70bc9f6f4439630e977eab903a089fc42cd8c" } ], "block_ids": [ "p0025", "p0026", "p0027" ], "source_segment_index": 6 }, { "q": "VI. A Tibetan example: a personal vow and the limit of ritual analogy", "a": "An [FPMT educational article on lay vows](https://fpmt.org/mandala/archives/mandala-issues-for-2006/june/which-vows-are-which-a-beginners-guide/), first published in 2006 with its five-precept section updated in 2020, describes a choice to take all five, some, or none. It explains the value placed on avoiding alcohol in that lineage and warns against using vows to judge other people. This is one Tibetan organization’s account, not a statement that every Vajrayāna school or teacher must use the same formulation.\n\nSome specialized tantric settings have objects and terms quite unlike ordinary lay life. A [2011 interview with one FPMT teacher](https://fpmt.org/mandala/archives/mandala-issues-for-2011/january/nine-questions-about-vegetarianism/) points both to the limits of such settings and to nonalcoholic alternatives for offerings. The interview is about vegetarianism, not the treatment of addiction; its separate historical and nutritional assertions are not being used here as health evidence. The existence of a ritual entails neither an obligation to drink nor the safety of alcohol for a person with a substance use disorder, medication, or a history of harm. That person can decline a drink and ask about an alternative without explaining a diagnosis to the whole group.\n\nEqually, complex symbolism cannot authorize everyone to set aside a medical plan, and a strict interpretation cannot by itself deliver treatment. If a spiritual teacher suggests a practice, it helps to ask what role and experience that teacher is offering. A clinician discussing alcohol risk has a different responsibility. With the patient’s consent, they may communicate; such communication is not a condition for starting care. A person can choose this community, another spiritual route, or none.", "source_spans": [ { "role": "h2_heading", "start_utf16": 10316, "end_utf16": 10385, "sha256_utf8": "13155fb5dc6eab9f28729c3c82cdc338d81ca5873473b93c35655d28a72bc380" }, { "role": "h2_answer", "start_utf16": 10387, "end_utf16": 12177, "sha256_utf8": "3fe152b6a1a3f2ca5c0239dd45cab4d4501bc8e44b230d1f2858142af0d3c377" } ], "block_ids": [ "p0029", "p0030", "p0031" ], "source_segment_index": 7 }, { "q": "VII. One word, different kinds of mindfulness", "a": "In a religious text, mindfulness may be part of a path. In a community, it may shape ordinary life. In a clinic, it may mean a structured program with a trained facilitator, duration, and criteria for participation. Reading about attention or sitting alone at home cannot be assumed to produce the same outcome as a studied program. The [US National Center for Complementary and Integrative Health (NCCIH)](https://www.nccih.nih.gov/health/meditation-and-mindfulness-effectiveness-and-safety) describes studies of mindfulness-based programs for substance use disorders. Some results concern reduced craving, but findings are mixed and do not show that such a program consistently prevents relapse better than other forms of help. The center also acknowledges gaps in research on adverse experiences and advises against using meditation in place of conventional care.\n\nA careful conclusion is possible: noticing one’s reactions can be part of agreed care for some people. For another person, a practice may bring distress, particularly alone or while highly anxious. Nobody has to sit through a dangerous condition, endure an intensive practice, or tell a group details of trauma. If a format makes matters worse, it can be stopped and another approach discussed with a qualified professional. This does not negate a practice’s spiritual value; it prevents that value from being advertised as universal treatment.\n\nMindfulness is not proved by flawless self-control. Pain, insomnia, medication, withdrawal, or danger at home may make concentration difficult. That is reason to adjust expectations and seek accessible support, not to make a moral judgment. Without an experienced guide, an online instruction for long or intense practice should not become a way to “wait out” a medical risk. This article distinguishes fields of care rather than prescribing an at-home technique.", "source_spans": [ { "role": "h2_heading", "start_utf16": 12182, "end_utf16": 12227, "sha256_utf8": "8d3bddf16a941a39d394be027359acf586f4d6b14dbaf7a40fce794b032d0f73" }, { "role": "h2_answer", "start_utf16": 12229, "end_utf16": 14106, "sha256_utf8": "2314e488ba802068f4bb0fd71113ae9b6004bfb1314ce47812c2fa85ff2ebd0a" } ], "block_ids": [ "p0033", "p0034", "p0035" ], "source_segment_index": 8 }, { "q": "VIII. When the body needs care, not a calmness test", "a": "The [NHS alcohol-use disorder page](https://www.nhs.uk/conditions/alcohol-use-disorder/) warns that abrupt cessation can be dangerous when a person is physically dependent on alcohol; medical advice should precede a planned change. That does not mean everyone who drinks is physically dependent, but it rules out giving everybody the same abrupt-stop advice. Where the situation is unclear, a professional can ask about the course of use, other health conditions, and medicines, then work with the person on a locally available route. This article provides no doses, timelines, or home withdrawal plan.\n\nPrescribed medicines need similar distinctions. In 2026 the [UK medicines regulator MHRA](https://www.gov.uk/government/news/mhra-strengthening-dependency-and-addiction-warnings-on-medicines-used-to-treat-pain-anxiety-and-insomnia) strengthened warnings concerning dependence, addiction, and withdrawal for certain medicines used for pain, anxiety, and insomnia. It advises against stopping a prescription without professional advice. A prescription, physical adaptation, and a substance use disorder are different claims. Neither a Buddhist word about intoxication nor a warning on a package diagnoses a person on its own. Benefits, risks, and alternatives can be discussed with the prescriber, including the patient’s own wish to observe a precept.\n\nThe priority is even clearer when health changes acutely. **Suspected poisoning means immediate contact with the local emergency medical service before symptoms. New sudden confusion means the same immediate contact on its own.** Do not explain it away as a “spiritual crisis,” a hangover, or inadequate meditation. A trusted adult in a community may help locate the service and, with consent, pass on known facts; a religious conversation cannot replace emergency assessment. A child or dependent adult also needs a suitable adult actually present to provide care, not merely a service’s number written down.", "source_spans": [ { "role": "h2_heading", "start_utf16": 14111, "end_utf16": 14162, "sha256_utf8": "439c7ad301b3e67a3f5f1167912c72e18814b8c6e869a4758007d6a557364a0e" }, { "role": "h2_answer", "start_utf16": 14164, "end_utf16": 16129, "sha256_utf8": "d8a751e4be94c953f6c9bed54ce7611cbdc4bae4ebe14a9cb807403e4d9f2847" } ], "block_ids": [ "p0037", "p0038", "p0039" ], "source_segment_index": 9 }, { "q": "IX. Compassion, limits, and family safety", "a": "Buddhist compassion is sometimes presented as a demand to endure everything until another person changes. Participation can be described more concretely. A relative may offer a ride to an appointment, help find a service, stay with a child for an agreed time, or state honestly what they cannot do. They are not obliged to control someone else’s sobriety, hide harm, or surrender their own safety. Their personal limits still have to account for care they already owe or have agreed to provide: a child needs food, protection, and an adult present; a dependent person needs an actual transfer of necessary care, not just the sentence “not my responsibility.”\n\nIf there are threats, coercion, or violence, the first route is **a separate safe way to contact local protection and medical services**, taking account of who can see a phone, message, or journey. Joint meditation, a family meeting, or reconciliation must not precede safety. Nobody should be required to investigate covertly at personal risk or disclose details of substance use or abuse to a group as a price of support. Confidentiality, reporting duties, housing, guardianship, and data access vary with place and age; this article makes no universal legal promise.\n\nChildren are not interpreters for a medical conversation, keepers of dangerous secrets, medicine monitors, or supervisors of adult sobriety. They need an age-appropriate explanation without responsibility for the result. If an adult needs to leave for care, another suitable adult must actually be available to look after the child; a service appointment is not child care. Compassion toward a person struggling with substance use is compatible with protecting everyone else in the family, including the person offering help.", "source_spans": [ { "role": "h2_heading", "start_utf16": 16134, "end_utf16": 16175, "sha256_utf8": "e0f96e8ad809115b1619d7c02471ef2d5c7c316ec6a9260b40e58f7a2f7016be" }, { "role": "h2_answer", "start_utf16": 16177, "end_utf16": 17933, "sha256_utf8": "e67a33108453aabaddf9da98cfb827170cbeae79f31da03d01674b0650a4b104" } ], "block_ids": [ "p0041", "p0042", "p0043" ], "source_segment_index": 10 }, { "q": "X. A first contact that can really happen", "a": "A plan need not begin with a promise of “perfect mindfulness.” If there is no immediate danger, a person can contact an accessible local health service and say which substance or medicine worries them, what happens when use changes, and what they need to understand now. They do not need a ready diagnosis or a promise of complete sobriety to ask for an assessment. If spiritual support is wanted, that is a separate voluntary conversation: what is available, whether participation requires public disclosure, and how the community treats prescribed care.\n\nBefore travel or booking, it helps to check language and interpretation, cost and insurance, waiting time, age rules, transport, confidentiality and data handling, and who will actually see the person. These questions matter especially to those who do not speak the local language fluently or live far from a service. “We have a group” is not a confirmed clinical appointment; a temple address is not housing; a service contact does not arrange adult care at home. When the first option does not fit, that is information for the next step, not proof that the person is “unready.”\n\nFor some, a Buddhist community provides a meaningful voluntary commitment and people who will be there. For others, secular care or a different faith community will fit better. None of these routes requires a humiliating confession, stopping needed medication, or proving willpower before the first conversation. Practical hope means recognizing danger, not mistaking a symbol for treatment, and keeping room to choose support that is actually available and safe.", "source_spans": [ { "role": "h2_heading", "start_utf16": 17938, "end_utf16": 17979, "sha256_utf8": "6331a6c29833fc2f4f375233758b59000ffde72448f7726cdf580bf4f197cb96" }, { "role": "h2_answer", "start_utf16": 17981, "end_utf16": 19582, "sha256_utf8": "96aacd93382c22b4d189b0324335598e0a2fe7384aa0a97e4fcf589cd0080a7a" } ], "block_ids": [ "p0045", "p0046", "p0047" ], "source_segment_index": 11 }, { "q": "What this means in practice", "a": "Separate three matters: **immediate danger**, **a question for professional assessment**, and **any spiritual support you want**. Suspected poisoning calls for immediate local emergency medical contact even before symptoms, and new sudden confusion calls for that contact on its own. Otherwise, ask a local service about a real appointment and how a change in substance use or prescribed treatment can be handled safely; check language, cost, waiting time, data, and care for anyone who depends on you. Then, if you wish, speak with a specific community about a precept or mindfulness practice. This is not a linear test: medical help is available to seek at any stage and regardless of belief.", "source_spans": [ { "role": "h2_heading", "start_utf16": 19587, "end_utf16": 19614, "sha256_utf8": "cac0025fb51e434450b9925cf9a4977d85e79dc5ce2542d61d4355abea0cdd54" }, { "role": "h2_answer", "start_utf16": 19616, "end_utf16": 20310, "sha256_utf8": "48a0af0301ba3d969310609db8aa62595535939441cb3ea7fb7a30818ce64696" } ], "block_ids": [ "p0049" ], "source_segment_index": 12 }, { "q": "Key quotation", "a": "> *Surāmerayamajjapamādaṭṭhānā paṭivirato hoti* — “Refrains from intoxicants that lead to heedlessness.” Our brief rendering of [Aṅguttara Nikāya 8.39](https://dhammatalks.net/suttacentral/sc2016/sc/pi/an8.39.html), World Tipiṭaka Edition, Roman Script, 2005. The phrase identifies an ethical practice, not a withdrawal regimen.", "source_spans": [ { "role": "h2_heading", "start_utf16": 20315, "end_utf16": 20328, "sha256_utf8": "b118466bf32094406f875582a1606883eea0c734aab123a1fe6f5352d863995a" }, { "role": "h2_answer", "start_utf16": 20330, "end_utf16": 20658, "sha256_utf8": "118f94fe07543f04cea519880aded7e0d118ccd9f0e7331f1cccff4b06686124" } ], "block_ids": [ "p0051" ], "source_segment_index": 13 }, { "q": "Connections across traditions", "a": "| Source or setting | What it helps distinguish | What it cannot establish |\n|---|---|---|\n| Pali *Dhammapada* 251, SN 56:11, and AN 8.39 | The image of craving, a middle way, and an ethic of clarity | Every cause of SUD, an individual diagnosis, or a home withdrawal instruction |\n| Amaravati, a British Theravāda community | Lay and monastic or retreat precepts; a prescription is not automatically recreational intoxication | A rule for all Theravāda or a medical service at the monastery |\n| Plum Village in Thich Nhat Hanh’s lineage | Mindful consumption as a particular voluntary community practice | One Mahāyāna position or a proven clinical cure |\n| FPMT in a Tibetan setting | A personal choice of lay vows and the need to read ritual language in context | A universal license to drink, safety of ritual alcohol, or a rule for all Vajrayāna |\n| Medical sources | Separate assessment of withdrawal, medicine, and acute danger | A replacement for spiritual meaning or a promise of local access |", "source_spans": [ { "role": "h2_heading", "start_utf16": 20663, "end_utf16": 20692, "sha256_utf8": "bbb2d1c354b1494b53423137cb6ec2e06b90d74e352cc5097170fe70a1d88721" }, { "role": "h2_answer", "start_utf16": 20694, "end_utf16": 21697, "sha256_utf8": "6067f4378384af6823ecb961cc56732a3009ccc48f4b043bdc4e47ef39360ccc" } ], "block_ids": [ "p0053" ], "source_segment_index": 14 }, { "q": "Sources and scope", "a": "1. [*Dhammapada* 251, World Tipiṭaka Edition Pali in Roman script, 2005](https://dhammatalks.net/suttacentral/sc2016/sc/pi/dhp.html). Static SuttaCentral archive; epigraph from the Pali.\n2. [SN 56:11, *Dhammacakkappavattana Sutta*, translated by Ṭhānissaro Bhikkhu](https://www.dhammatalks.org/suttas/SN/SN56_11.html). Modern rendering of an early Pali discourse; date of this web version not established.\n3. [AN 8.39, *Abhisandasutta*, World Tipiṭaka Edition Pali in Roman script, 2005](https://dhammatalks.net/suttacentral/sc2016/sc/pi/an8.39.html). Static archive; key quotation from the Pali.\n4. [Amaravati Buddhist Monastery, FAQ](https://amaravati.org/visiting/frequently-asked-questions/). Official local UK monastery information; revision date not shown in the inspected passage.\n5. [Ajahn Candasiri, *Simple Kindness*, Amaravati, 2012](https://cdn.amaravati.org/wp-content/uploads/2014/09/Simple_Kindness_-_Ajahn_Candasiri.pdf). Book of talks; only a brief original synthesis of a bounded passage is used.\n6. [Plum Village, *The Five Mindfulness Trainings*, revised 15 June 2022](https://plumvillage.org/mindfulness/the-5-mindfulness-trainings). Text of one community.\n7. [FPMT *Mandala*, *Which Vows Are Which?*, June 2006; five-precepts section updated July 2020](https://fpmt.org/mandala/archives/mandala-issues-for-2006/june/which-vows-are-which-a-beginners-guide/). Educational article from one Tibetan organization.\n8. [FPMT *Mandala*, interview with Geshe Thubten Soepa, January–March 2011](https://fpmt.org/mandala/archives/mandala-issues-for-2011/january/nine-questions-about-vegetarianism/). Narrow illustration of ritual context, not a medical source or a policy for all schools.\n9. [NCCIH, *Meditation and Mindfulness: Effectiveness and Safety*](https://www.nccih.nih.gov/health/meditation-and-mindfulness-effectiveness-and-safety). US government information summary; the observed page’s full update history and its cited studies were not independently examined.\n10. [NHS, *Alcohol-use disorder*, reviewed 24 April 2026](https://www.nhs.uk/conditions/alcohol-use-disorder/). UK public medical guidance.\n11. [NHS, *Sudden confusion*, reviewed 28 May 2024](https://www.nhs.uk/symptoms/confusion/). UK public medical guidance.\n12. [NHS, *Poisoning*, reviewed 12 June 2025](https://www.nhs.uk/conditions/Poisoning/). UK public medical guidance.\n13. [MHRA, regulator news release, 8 January 2026](https://www.gov.uk/government/news/mhra-strengthening-dependency-and-addiction-warnings-on-medicines-used-to-treat-pain-anxiety-and-insomnia). UK warnings for some prescribed medicines.", "source_spans": [ { "role": "h2_heading", "start_utf16": 21702, "end_utf16": 21719, "sha256_utf8": "21cabd412236bd59d9b3f70f3d6ab42e4fb5fbd631f455218358e9dbda365336" }, { "role": "h2_answer", "start_utf16": 21721, "end_utf16": 24319, "sha256_utf8": "4540011ab07fac2cb4055e473ae12868b3938bfde878fb6cac6011fcd0052213" } ], "block_ids": [ "p0055" ], "source_segment_index": 15 }, { "q": "Tags", "a": "Buddhism · addiction · craving · attachment · mindfulness · fifth precept · Theravāda · Mahāyāna · Vajrayāna · sobriety · medical care · unity of traditions", "source_spans": [ { "role": "h2_heading", "start_utf16": 24324, "end_utf16": 24328, "sha256_utf8": "1331275bc537b4c2bf1e46f7275677967515342e30b572e6852fa6f51b831fe8" }, { "role": "h2_answer", "start_utf16": 24330, "end_utf16": 24486, "sha256_utf8": "18a0cd7b6937c7499f751f9e8a5657188571af452ade55ab49df48dc3adeb53a" } ], "block_ids": [ "p0057" ], "source_segment_index": 16 }, { "q": "About the authors", "a": "Andrey Zarinsh is the author and founder of United Wisdom. He explores inner transformation, the unity of traditions, intercultural dialogue, and contemporary spiritual discipline. Instagram: @andrey.zarinsh.\n\nMaria Evilkut is a co-author of United Wisdom. Alongside her research, she seeks to test these ideas in practice and observe how unity and mutual understanding work in real life among people and cultures. Instagram: @ilkutki.", "source_spans": [ { "role": "h2_heading", "start_utf16": 24491, "end_utf16": 24508, "sha256_utf8": "e120452a2b9952200310f55df00e52d0bbd068d32bba8a322511ed65e3d4967d" }, { "role": "h2_answer", "start_utf16": 24510, "end_utf16": 24945, "sha256_utf8": "bcfd0f6dfc41ef1aede4663efe40ada7487440dfdd6108c9f49069e258c7a937" } ], "block_ids": [ "p0059", "p0060" ], "source_segment_index": 17 } ], "claims": [], "claims_policy": "no_reclassified_claims", "sources": [ { "id": "src_83e66a7afa9ddb14", "title": "*Dhammapada* 251, World Tipiṭaka Edition Pali in Roman script, 2005", "url": "https://dhammatalks.net/suttacentral/sc2016/sc/pi/dhp.html", "source_spans": [ { "role": "markdown_link", "start_utf16": 208, "end_utf16": 286, "sha256_utf8": "02336a22fd271a7214d48432f131b540e0ed56b9d742eb009280255b3d4f4fbf" }, { "role": "markdown_link", "start_utf16": 2679, "end_utf16": 2763, "sha256_utf8": "3b08cf4629fb2e7627c22ce22ee6848d70a545774e8c6b94662a8a6ab407d9d2" }, { "role": "markdown_link", "start_utf16": 21724, "end_utf16": 21853, "sha256_utf8": "9b1ae5d64c2e0824211d31e962e2c65eb9d953a21fc2b24efb6f70000d123897" } ], "read_scope": "1. [*Dhammapada* 251, World Tipiṭaka Edition Pali in Roman script, 2005](https://dhammatalks.net/suttacentral/sc2016/sc/pi/dhp.html). Static SuttaCentral archive; epigraph from the Pali.", "read_scope_kind": "verbatim_bibliography_entry", "read_scope_span": { "role": "bibliography_entry", "start_utf16": 21721, "end_utf16": 21907, "sha256_utf8": "a4451e9f6465c142ccbba03614d7cca76b2d4d9f37e1152ffc55f26fd8a1e1ca" }, "shared_entry_urls": [] }, { "id": "src_e91af7fc69dbdcd9", "title": "NHS, *Poisoning*, reviewed 12 June 2025", "url": "https://www.nhs.uk/conditions/Poisoning/", "source_spans": [ { "role": "markdown_link", "start_utf16": 1708, "end_utf16": 1770, "sha256_utf8": "c8d0e70a664caf59942c9b9b3f1097e5fa6064be4ad63e78193626ddb2ecc637" }, { "role": "markdown_link", "start_utf16": 23970, "end_utf16": 24053, "sha256_utf8": "7f9b500524d6c6d9209c7e45b6ddf060fb6e4860403195d4eb713739d8284294" } ], "read_scope": "12. [NHS, *Poisoning*, reviewed 12 June 2025](https://www.nhs.uk/conditions/Poisoning/). UK public medical guidance.", "read_scope_kind": "verbatim_bibliography_entry", "read_scope_span": { "role": "bibliography_entry", "start_utf16": 23966, "end_utf16": 24082, "sha256_utf8": "b3762683defbfbbbfaaac2f786d359030d9f010101055719b844d26e22303889" }, "shared_entry_urls": [] }, { "id": "src_6740eb80d2b869e3", "title": "NHS, *Sudden confusion*, reviewed 28 May 2024", "url": "https://www.nhs.uk/symptoms/confusion/", "source_spans": [ { "role": "markdown_link", "start_utf16": 1948, "end_utf16": 2008, "sha256_utf8": "e1714a28a94d0972ca82ce4b8df5608e248d19a5a89fffc00d1986e9de7bdd49" }, { "role": "markdown_link", "start_utf16": 23849, "end_utf16": 23936, "sha256_utf8": "92ffa36abe9c496dd83601dfa41026ae10d09f06b3fb660e7a127dba6ee47903" } ], "read_scope": "11. [NHS, *Sudden confusion*, reviewed 28 May 2024](https://www.nhs.uk/symptoms/confusion/). UK public medical guidance.", "read_scope_kind": "verbatim_bibliography_entry", "read_scope_span": { "role": "bibliography_entry", "start_utf16": 23845, "end_utf16": 23965, "sha256_utf8": "46ae497887cefc7475b050c067e3058b1609563bed0af5d5850bb68656b83e02" }, "shared_entry_urls": [] }, { "id": "src_4dd06b8ee8c5e692", "title": "SN 56:11, *Dhammacakkappavattana Sutta*, translated by Ṭhānissaro Bhikkhu", "url": "https://www.dhammatalks.org/suttas/SN/SN56_11.html", "source_spans": [ { "role": "markdown_link", "start_utf16": 3772, "end_utf16": 3869, "sha256_utf8": "5b1da0119715218eedffee923c3d7f700abcdd7d51402d98c2706d439c6b36fc" }, { "role": "markdown_link", "start_utf16": 21911, "end_utf16": 22038, "sha256_utf8": "9030a055eb1fdec9c54fed3693b1476185fe410d6f7090afbb27ec74055a4597" } ], "read_scope": "2. [SN 56:11, *Dhammacakkappavattana Sutta*, translated by Ṭhānissaro Bhikkhu](https://www.dhammatalks.org/suttas/SN/SN56_11.html). Modern rendering of an early Pali discourse; date of this web version not established.", "read_scope_kind": "verbatim_bibliography_entry", "read_scope_span": { "role": "bibliography_entry", "start_utf16": 21908, "end_utf16": 22126, "sha256_utf8": "830ee3181c5391c13aa22b4998ee9175b06ac9515cefcb0538995b7805c29a8f" }, "shared_entry_urls": [] }, { "id": "src_244e3a55f58bb3b5", "title": "AN 8.39, *Abhisandasutta*, World Tipiṭaka Edition Pali in Roman script, 2005", "url": "https://dhammatalks.net/suttacentral/sc2016/sc/pi/an8.39.html", "source_spans": [ { "role": "markdown_link", "start_utf16": 5466, "end_utf16": 5560, "sha256_utf8": "3942b712a4a19be3b01f2335449892585f277d6bff5ff817b39462826537eb44" }, { "role": "markdown_link", "start_utf16": 20458, "end_utf16": 20544, "sha256_utf8": "510f57b5b136e864caba9d46811f1ef33ad5590450d081e3be927f9a0db4965d" }, { "role": "markdown_link", "start_utf16": 22130, "end_utf16": 22271, "sha256_utf8": "35ca2b6ddab535c566fd084254b395b062345eef3874b01fab742f2da529af05" } ], "read_scope": "3. [AN 8.39, *Abhisandasutta*, World Tipiṭaka Edition Pali in Roman script, 2005](https://dhammatalks.net/suttacentral/sc2016/sc/pi/an8.39.html). Static archive; key quotation from the Pali.", "read_scope_kind": "verbatim_bibliography_entry", "read_scope_span": { "role": "bibliography_entry", "start_utf16": 22127, "end_utf16": 22317, "sha256_utf8": "ff9f5921d2482578c2a75a56118c11751b115d3b90544278e0d38d7b4c899eb4" }, "shared_entry_urls": [] }, { "id": "src_3b94412f173b73a7", "title": "Amaravati Buddhist Monastery, FAQ", "url": "https://amaravati.org/visiting/frequently-asked-questions/", "source_spans": [ { "role": "markdown_link", "start_utf16": 7001, "end_utf16": 7113, "sha256_utf8": "eb2c5538c90d99f5ff79313d37c09a75d8f5945e498783f7a69be8cee65d92eb" }, { "role": "markdown_link", "start_utf16": 22321, "end_utf16": 22416, "sha256_utf8": "70af0cb1b467b21f523c64572bac88e7152026ee307b1d58813f331a6d50936c" } ], "read_scope": "4. [Amaravati Buddhist Monastery, FAQ](https://amaravati.org/visiting/frequently-asked-questions/). Official local UK monastery information; revision date not shown in the inspected passage.", "read_scope_kind": "verbatim_bibliography_entry", "read_scope_span": { "role": "bibliography_entry", "start_utf16": 22318, "end_utf16": 22508, "sha256_utf8": "ffaf7d20eb9e55124b5cb95e8ddfb5ae79e81cddaa6ff6bd5cb50df9a358d0f4" }, "shared_entry_urls": [] }, { "id": "src_7f090b4a3ad4d1e9", "title": "Ajahn Candasiri, *Simple Kindness*, Amaravati, 2012", "url": "https://cdn.amaravati.org/wp-content/uploads/2014/09/Simple_Kindness_-_Ajahn_Candasiri.pdf", "source_spans": [ { "role": "markdown_link", "start_utf16": 7597, "end_utf16": 7741, "sha256_utf8": "42fa06b8fe9ff6a3d584c3c24355f49cf422057c1fdb71f45d305084bfb75275" }, { "role": "markdown_link", "start_utf16": 22512, "end_utf16": 22657, "sha256_utf8": "232c182dd29982deffc5ea99cebfddee5fb79e2979d55af6e68263b33e83b210" } ], "read_scope": "5. [Ajahn Candasiri, *Simple Kindness*, Amaravati, 2012](https://cdn.amaravati.org/wp-content/uploads/2014/09/Simple_Kindness_-_Ajahn_Candasiri.pdf). Book of talks; only a brief original synthesis of a bounded passage is used.", "read_scope_kind": "verbatim_bibliography_entry", "read_scope_span": { "role": "bibliography_entry", "start_utf16": 22509, "end_utf16": 22735, "sha256_utf8": "7644cdb2018a5278d5976659b45b9b15b0d7b74a91f3189ceda8ce27daf3bafa" }, "shared_entry_urls": [] }, { "id": "src_809cc8993334da96", "title": "Plum Village, *The Five Mindfulness Trainings*, revised 15 June 2022", "url": "https://plumvillage.org/mindfulness/the-5-mindfulness-trainings", "source_spans": [ { "role": "markdown_link", "start_utf16": 8750, "end_utf16": 8858, "sha256_utf8": "8dda448ac331688f9a0a72fe34d4c87432f7050146fa09057a8248306bbc29e2" }, { "role": "markdown_link", "start_utf16": 22739, "end_utf16": 22874, "sha256_utf8": "791b2566ff07437fd1c7773a979a74db3dee4a61b57a249f0fd5b1292d30eeaf" } ], "read_scope": "6. [Plum Village, *The Five Mindfulness Trainings*, revised 15 June 2022](https://plumvillage.org/mindfulness/the-5-mindfulness-trainings). Text of one community.", "read_scope_kind": "verbatim_bibliography_entry", "read_scope_span": { "role": "bibliography_entry", "start_utf16": 22736, "end_utf16": 22898, "sha256_utf8": "fe62187d501d6600843e7646323da2928e5242a870bc54210f0e13d2a76be95b" }, "shared_entry_urls": [] }, { "id": "src_16c272c014ea74f3", "title": "FPMT *Mandala*, *Which Vows Are Which?*, June 2006; five-precepts section updated July 2020", "url": "https://fpmt.org/mandala/archives/mandala-issues-for-2006/june/which-vows-are-which-a-beginners-guide/", "source_spans": [ { "role": "markdown_link", "start_utf16": 10390, "end_utf16": 10532, "sha256_utf8": "de1bc3c4dd3e209b25578994a0ec77f4b81020627a1b0217ff6a938c28aaa14c" }, { "role": "markdown_link", "start_utf16": 22902, "end_utf16": 23099, "sha256_utf8": "0fc36be84d8e4eb5823e6529f73fd4a098ab545f905ef9b86e2b7ea56cddf948" } ], "read_scope": "7. [FPMT *Mandala*, *Which Vows Are Which?*, June 2006; five-precepts section updated July 2020](https://fpmt.org/mandala/archives/mandala-issues-for-2006/june/which-vows-are-which-a-beginners-guide/). Educational article from one Tibetan organization.", "read_scope_kind": "verbatim_bibliography_entry", "read_scope_span": { "role": "bibliography_entry", "start_utf16": 22899, "end_utf16": 23151, "sha256_utf8": "30c79c0cd01049606a2e11adff4de0e224a47becea63b5ba58c692119aa71d2b" }, "shared_entry_urls": [] }, { "id": "src_11d6dae510c54d39", "title": "FPMT *Mandala*, interview with Geshe Thubten Soepa, January–March 2011", "url": "https://fpmt.org/mandala/archives/mandala-issues-for-2011/january/nine-questions-about-vegetarianism/", "source_spans": [ { "role": "markdown_link", "start_utf16": 10996, "end_utf16": 11137, "sha256_utf8": "289aa73179bf8d41d89edb9770b4f532c69f4117befbfb46f264ec9b6efdab94" }, { "role": "markdown_link", "start_utf16": 23155, "end_utf16": 23330, "sha256_utf8": "5de28f83d201e3133596ab25284ab35beace7f863d9c63b0fb00ba1c0241f024" } ], "read_scope": "8. [FPMT *Mandala*, interview with Geshe Thubten Soepa, January–March 2011](https://fpmt.org/mandala/archives/mandala-issues-for-2011/january/nine-questions-about-vegetarianism/). Narrow illustration of ritual context, not a medical source or a policy for all schools.", "read_scope_kind": "verbatim_bibliography_entry", "read_scope_span": { "role": "bibliography_entry", "start_utf16": 23152, "end_utf16": 23420, "sha256_utf8": "d1c2b5ca5b0550ffc47a08eb083908c859eb3322d79fbb77b993446f4e287efe" }, "shared_entry_urls": [] }, { "id": "src_de6160f860161699", "title": "NCCIH, *Meditation and Mindfulness: Effectiveness and Safety*", "url": "https://www.nccih.nih.gov/health/meditation-and-mindfulness-effectiveness-and-safety", "source_spans": [ { "role": "markdown_link", "start_utf16": 12566, "end_utf16": 12721, "sha256_utf8": "c870f345d0ed417de5617bc6e8b092d242ce50ae283c42d0141d66e3c751aa25" }, { "role": "markdown_link", "start_utf16": 23424, "end_utf16": 23573, "sha256_utf8": "86c6f7e104fefcce3c93268949c574685b1b13ec23f9b3d3ea8031cb111da2cf" } ], "read_scope": "9. [NCCIH, *Meditation and Mindfulness: Effectiveness and Safety*](https://www.nccih.nih.gov/health/meditation-and-mindfulness-effectiveness-and-safety). US government information summary; the observed page’s full update history and its cited studies were not independently examined.", "read_scope_kind": "verbatim_bibliography_entry", "read_scope_span": { "role": "bibliography_entry", "start_utf16": 23421, "end_utf16": 23704, "sha256_utf8": "50708611e0d2a04cd92ee96a2916da9c49dbd243a182006eae501b45aecf3c1d" }, "shared_entry_urls": [] }, { "id": "src_7c21d186f34ec948", "title": "NHS, *Alcohol-use disorder*, reviewed 24 April 2026", "url": "https://www.nhs.uk/conditions/alcohol-use-disorder/", "source_spans": [ { "role": "markdown_link", "start_utf16": 14168, "end_utf16": 14252, "sha256_utf8": "6e4c8d0de133362b021e0d06aeca3e9a5a5a5967ce428ae5f920bdcabbc3b5ad" }, { "role": "markdown_link", "start_utf16": 23709, "end_utf16": 23815, "sha256_utf8": "9af42922c85dc88f00c10ce0f12ec3c624542bc02b9a32a843f1d81c7a9cdca9" } ], "read_scope": "10. [NHS, *Alcohol-use disorder*, reviewed 24 April 2026](https://www.nhs.uk/conditions/alcohol-use-disorder/). UK public medical guidance.", "read_scope_kind": "verbatim_bibliography_entry", "read_scope_span": { "role": "bibliography_entry", "start_utf16": 23705, "end_utf16": 23844, "sha256_utf8": "303b5776d7ad577ef0e3aee4cdc7c8a5dc1d5a3c935366a7c372d0d0e178517d" }, "shared_entry_urls": [] }, { "id": "src_76cfa71460490484", "title": "MHRA, regulator news release, 8 January 2026", "url": "https://www.gov.uk/government/news/mhra-strengthening-dependency-and-addiction-warnings-on-medicines-used-to-treat-pain-anxiety-and-insomnia", "source_spans": [ { "role": "markdown_link", "start_utf16": 14828, "end_utf16": 14999, "sha256_utf8": "369d1dddc5db529433a108a99bf8b9aee04c1fba861ebcd3053d7d761696076b" }, { "role": "markdown_link", "start_utf16": 24087, "end_utf16": 24275, "sha256_utf8": "2765de07b28cdaccb485916c06e7aead5868e2c9fd55ba1d0b6059436ba478b1" } ], "read_scope": "13. [MHRA, regulator news release, 8 January 2026](https://www.gov.uk/government/news/mhra-strengthening-dependency-and-addiction-warnings-on-medicines-used-to-treat-pain-anxiety-and-insomnia). UK warnings for some prescribed medicines.", "read_scope_kind": "verbatim_bibliography_entry", "read_scope_span": { "role": "bibliography_entry", "start_utf16": 24083, "end_utf16": 24319, "sha256_utf8": "a7a8f3d95af2167b6acaf4f7dfc465916f6cfdfa98fd3003aac5db67a1af1aab" }, "shared_entry_urls": [] } ], "retrieval_limits": [ "This local GEO representation applies only to the specified source article version and its SHA-256.", "Qualifications, sources and attributions remain in the full sections and byte-identical Markdown copy.", "No new source research was conducted in this GEO stage." ], "master_sha256": "2c8e3a626842ab2aaf00f3ffcfc751c9f18edd96caf7c6687bf4b368abfd94a3", "provenance": { "raw_reader_sha256": "2c8e3a626842ab2aaf00f3ffcfc751c9f18edd96caf7c6687bf4b368abfd94a3", "ru_master_sha256": "6b889500df0483c8a536ee233c6153a24ef29889cc6db9592a5a19e3dcba261a", "reader_path": "outputs/uw-addictions-corpus-20261013/articles/DEP-20-N07/ARTICLE_EN.md", "review_pointer": "outputs/uw-addictions-corpus-20261013/articles/DEP-20-N07/INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.json", "review_sha256": "5c6e398daf5b2fb1f1774b149b8b7cc94f2372575987e9960c6fbfd8e38429e7", "clean_md_relative_filename": "GEO.en.md", "body_length_utf16": 24946, "source_segments": [ { "kind": "opening", "index": 0, "heading": null, "start_utf16": 0, "end_utf16": 467, "sha256_utf8_raw_slice": "9541bbcc042485c62c3c3c8e7a450edb8e5d64e3ac175f86cf8cdd4fb8af01cd" }, { "kind": "h2_section", "index": 1, "heading": "What this article is about", "start_utf16": 467, "end_utf16": 2152, "sha256_utf8_raw_slice": "3a1c930ffec2e070e3a04c26820a34a5aa03bffd8dca3faeba8876b301071056" }, { "kind": "h2_section", "index": 2, "heading": "I. First ask who is speaking, and to whom", "start_utf16": 2152, "end_utf16": 3692, "sha256_utf8_raw_slice": "a808358be0885a82c33c97a37e5327a515cb8d7f0b974e7cf319fb9d22170651" }, { "kind": "h2_section", "index": 3, "heading": "II. A doctrinal craving is not a diagnosis", "start_utf16": 3692, "end_utf16": 5388, "sha256_utf8_raw_slice": "0c4806b6c4c7798fedfe7a9190f11954a956b18abc50534a86527124fe8afcf3" }, { "kind": "h2_section", "index": 4, "heading": "III. The fifth precept is an ethic of clarity, not home withdrawal advice", "start_utf16": 5388, "end_utf16": 6945, "sha256_utf8_raw_slice": "0c1d16d502389ed52aa49843216be3811e1c0a79697947e9516d12d32b05f5f3" }, { "kind": "h2_section", "index": 5, "heading": "IV. Theravāda: monastery conditions and lay life", "start_utf16": 6945, "end_utf16": 8684, "sha256_utf8_raw_slice": "4490e3a6821308fabab865b8b4200bced6faf6d5fc25a71a80a4cbaba25ce07d" }, { "kind": "h2_section", "index": 6, "heading": "V. Plum Village: mindful consumption as a community choice", "start_utf16": 8684, "end_utf16": 10313, "sha256_utf8_raw_slice": "b84e522931e3d3fbeb547a00e09f5e6291fa4617f4ac8551878a3f9433cad063" }, { "kind": "h2_section", "index": 7, "heading": "VI. A Tibetan example: a personal vow and the limit of ritual analogy", "start_utf16": 10313, "end_utf16": 12179, "sha256_utf8_raw_slice": "817b7dcf28c2c7e7cf6c88031f5dad5973f78f99c4782c5c6bd0c3c4a4c49de6" }, { "kind": "h2_section", "index": 8, "heading": "VII. One word, different kinds of mindfulness", "start_utf16": 12179, "end_utf16": 14108, "sha256_utf8_raw_slice": "cce14277ed80a5eaeaaeee78694015d93d93b1ce74588f9d053544ad25544f80" }, { "kind": "h2_section", "index": 9, "heading": "VIII. When the body needs care, not a calmness test", "start_utf16": 14108, "end_utf16": 16131, "sha256_utf8_raw_slice": "64f58b798c375a50c448edf58573837462f46d4f608d5952a56750e9f2df6e3a" }, { "kind": "h2_section", "index": 10, "heading": "IX. Compassion, limits, and family safety", "start_utf16": 16131, "end_utf16": 17935, "sha256_utf8_raw_slice": "77f06fa8a931adbb0aff879ef997b1798a51c6b6014caefeb5c72363298f643a" }, { "kind": "h2_section", "index": 11, "heading": "X. A first contact that can really happen", "start_utf16": 17935, "end_utf16": 19584, "sha256_utf8_raw_slice": "cbfdb2471e324fc7e44ebd459fcfe94c7e12e057e7699a85450259b8838dfe39" }, { "kind": "h2_section", "index": 12, "heading": "What this means in practice", "start_utf16": 19584, "end_utf16": 20312, "sha256_utf8_raw_slice": "548b1c25bd04953257471c7df34254b1488343b70a0f5ed444caec98a4a9ef84" }, { "kind": "h2_section", "index": 13, "heading": "Key quotation", "start_utf16": 20312, "end_utf16": 20660, "sha256_utf8_raw_slice": "29bf6db894cbec1c7ee832d3d5287bb1e43821d4e641b755a5df3fc8d316568d" }, { "kind": "h2_section", "index": 14, "heading": "Connections across traditions", "start_utf16": 20660, "end_utf16": 21699, "sha256_utf8_raw_slice": "f44abd9981450015fe0e4841a7a7550bbc6433faebf4e3c317a37471e759c467" }, { "kind": "h2_section", "index": 15, "heading": "Sources and scope", "start_utf16": 21699, "end_utf16": 24321, "sha256_utf8_raw_slice": "28f4bb3ae8617b0b27e2c0845300073638b533561ef340dccacde5c17af6fa4f" }, { "kind": "h2_section", "index": 16, "heading": "Tags", "start_utf16": 24321, "end_utf16": 24488, "sha256_utf8_raw_slice": "4fe93fd540f687f566221f820e23c08f39d8b179edbc392c894ece9db5f15903" }, { "kind": "h2_section", "index": 17, "heading": "About the authors", "start_utf16": 24488, "end_utf16": 24946, "sha256_utf8_raw_slice": "e0fea046348971e03b89821a5eb9f33ba6bcbf49e92250166caa8253310641fd" } ], "common_blocks_module_sha256": "6cf638661a819f960c39d08058bf6d0d0696e8b816f677d95b389f5f1d11e4d2" } }