{"article_index":"R-29-N05","catalog_id":"R-29-N05","claims":[{"article_sections":["I. A need does not specify its solution"],"attribution":"Editorial argument; historical sources are used only in the named comparison.","id":"C1","source_ids":[],"text":"An observed need does not specify one method of help.","type":"editorial_inference_hypothetical"},{"article_sections":["II. A voice must be able to change the plan"],"attribution":"Editorial argument; historical sources are used only in the named comparison.","id":"C2","source_ids":[],"text":"Participation includes being able to change or stop a proposed action.","type":"editorial_inference_hypothetical"},{"article_sections":["III. An offer does not create an indefinite mandate"],"attribution":"Editorial argument; historical sources are used only in the named comparison.","id":"C3","source_ids":[],"text":"A limited mandate does not transfer control over someone’s entire life.","type":"editorial_inference_hypothetical"},{"article_sections":["IV. Resources and authority are different"],"attribution":"Editorial argument; historical sources are used only in the named comparison.","id":"C4","source_ids":[],"text":"Offering a resource and deciding whether to accept it belong to different parties.","type":"editorial_inference_hypothetical"},{"article_sections":["V. Shared life does not remove differences"],"attribution":"Editorial argument; historical sources are used only in the named comparison.","id":"C5","source_ids":["B17-R-29-N05-S1"],"text":"Addams’s historical flexibility of methods supplies a limited comparison.","type":"editorial_inference_hypothetical"},{"article_sections":["VI. Representation needs a separate answer"],"attribution":"Editorial argument; historical sources are used only in the named comparison.","id":"C6","source_ids":["B17-R-29-N05-S2"],"text":"A resource offered through help does not replace permission to publish.","type":"editorial_inference_hypothetical"},{"article_sections":["VII. Gratitude is not payment through obedience"],"attribution":"Editorial argument; historical sources are used only in the named comparison.","id":"C7","source_ids":[],"text":"Gratitude for a completed action is not consent to subsequent actions.","type":"editorial_inference_hypothetical"},{"article_sections":["VIII. Examine the result against the agreed task"],"attribution":"Editorial argument; historical sources are used only in the named comparison.","id":"C8","source_ids":[],"text":"The result is examined within the agreed task.","type":"editorial_inference_hypothetical"}],"description":"How help preserves the recipient’s purpose, voice, and right to revise without appropriating their private story.","entities":["Jane Addams","Samuel D. Warren","Louis D. Brandeis","solidarity","recipient voice","delegation"],"headline":"Solidarity That Preserves the Recipient’s Voice","language":"en","master_sha256":"e87af56c21fb2cf58b38017aad922ac9e17b6fb52db172dd5d9f1905a870ebee","questions":[{"a":"No. Knowing which option does not fit already helps clarify the hypothetical task.","article_sections":["I. A need does not specify its solution"],"q":"Must someone have a finished plan to decline an item?","source_ids":[]},{"a":"Yes, with an understood topic, disclosure boundary, and way to end the mandate. Delegation is not labelled weakness.","article_sections":["VI. Representation needs a separate answer"],"q":"May someone delegate a conversation to a helper?","source_ids":[]},{"a":"The article distinguishes gratitude, liking a resource, and wanting to continue. Accepted promises are considered separately.","article_sections":["VII. Gratitude is not payment through obedience"],"q":"Must the relationship continue after help?","source_ids":[]}],"retrieval_limits":["Hypothetical neighbourhood initiative; no examined contemporary organisation or empirical effectiveness.","Historical settlement account and legal argument do not establish present law or publication safety.","No diagnoses, inferred motives, required gratitude or guaranteed benefit.","Practice voluntary, limited, and stops under threat/coercion/dangerous dependence.","Source fragments appear only in reader blocks; service fields contain pointers only."],"schema_version":"uw.editorial_geo.v1","short_answer":"Agree separately on the result, resource, mandate, and information to share. The recipient’s answer must affect help’s scope; both sides retain refusal and limits.","sources":[{"author":"Jane Addams","checked_at":"2026-10-08","evidence_type":"historical_authorial_argument","id":"B17-R-29-N05-S1","read_scope":"Gutenberg header/licence and title/contents0–56; version provenance and complete preface135–155; actual continuous selected Chapter VI context697–718, with additional earlier argument670. Not a claim to read the whole chapter or book. Fresh primary continuous rendered676–787 actually read; both selected authorial reader fragments come from713/714. This is selected book context, not whole-book reading.","rights_notes":"Gutenberg header identifies territorial applicability and instructs readers outside the United States to check local law. No universal public-domain or reuse-licence assertion; link and two short contextual fragments only.","rights_status":"UNKNOWN_GLOBAL_STATUS_SHORT_CONTEXTUAL_USE","title":"Twenty Years at Hull-House; with Autobiographical Notes","url":"https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/1325/pg1325-images.html","use_limit":"Two brief authorial reader fragments, within root fresh remaining14combinedRUEN words; whole book including reprinted essay is one work.","work_id":"jane-addams-twenty-years-at-hull-house-1910"},{"author":"Samuel D. Warren and Louis D. Brandeis","checked_at":"2026-10-08","evidence_type":"historical_legal_argument","id":"B17-R-29-N05-S2","read_scope":"Title/publication and continuous opening59–71; selected continuous argument108–141. Historical legal argument only; current law and whole article not claimed.","rights_notes":"Gutenberg 1890 Harvard Law Review article version. Global rights status is not determined. This packet uses a link and bounded historical paraphrase only, with no direct source quotations.","rights_status":"UNKNOWN_GLOBAL_STATUS_SHORT_CONTEXTUAL_USE","title":"The Right to Privacy","url":"https://www.gutenberg.org/files/37368/37368-h/37368-h.htm","use_limit":"Brief bounded historical paraphrase only; no direct quotations, present law, publication safety or removal guarantees.","work_id":"warren-brandeis-the-right-to-privacy-1890"}]}