{"article_index":"P-15-N05","catalog_id":"P-15-N05","claims":[{"article_sections":["II. Intense feeling and a clinical decision are different","IX. First contact can begin with an incomplete question"],"attribution":"NHS grief: difficult coping, worsening anxiety/low mood and insufficient personal efforts; original distinction in II.","id":"C01","limitations":"No diagnosis, universal calendar or individual assessment is supplied.","source_ids":["B30-P-15-N05-S3"],"text":"Varied grief does not exclude professional assessment of particular difficulties.","type":"official health information with editorial distinction"},{"article_sections":["III. A diagnostic duration is not a waiting period for help"],"attribution":"APA describes a particular category and context; section III distinguishes requesting help from clinical judgement.","id":"C02","limitations":"The complete DSM-5-TR was not read; no reader’s category or treatment is established.","source_ids":["B30-P-15-N05-S4"],"text":"Duration requirements for a particular diagnostic category are not a waiting period before requesting help.","type":"editorial clarification of official diagnostic information"},{"article_sections":["IV. Aristotle: a general account does not settle a particular case","V. Sirach: making room for the physician while retaining faith’s differences","X. Care need not wait for philosophical perfection"],"attribution":"Aristotle II.2, 4, 5 and Sirach 38:1–14 with critical context 15–23; sections IV–V and map.","id":"C03","limitations":"Transfer no historical remedy, moral blame or short mourning rule into modern care.","source_ids":["B30-P-15-N05-S1","B30-P-15-N05-S2"],"text":"Ancient ethics and a religious text can discuss care but replace no contemporary medical grounds.","type":"bounded primary comparison"},{"article_sections":["VIII. Immediate safety waits for neither explanation nor a calendar","What this means in practice"],"attribution":"NHS urgent help: immediate danger and safety; section VIII.","id":"C04","limitations":"No individual risk assessment or supplied local number. Page review 2023 and due 2026 already past are explicitly limited.","source_ids":["B30-P-15-N05-S5"],"text":"Life at risk or inability to maintain safety requires immediate professional assistance.","type":"official safety information"}],"description":"When to discuss professional help with grief: particular difficulties, limits of self-diagnosis, diagnostic duration versus consultation, and immediate safety.","headline":"When professional help is needed in grief","language":"en","master_sha256":"32f8fc0e9e4477ec1e84cbd70091d0ce05c708dcb959cead377d3d7ff2926596","questions":[{"a":"A category’s duration does not forbid earlier discussion of assistance. Request and diagnosis differ; immediate danger must not wait.","article_sections":["III. A diagnostic duration is not a waiting period for help","VIII. Immediate safety waits for neither explanation nor a calendar"],"q":"Must a diagnostic duration expire before I seek help?","source_ids":["B30-P-15-N05-S4","B30-P-15-N05-S5"]},{"a":"Contact concerns particular difficulties and should not define memory’s entire meaning in advance. Name the concern and ask what is being assessed and offered.","article_sections":["VI. Seeking assistance does not betray memory","IX. First contact can begin with an incomplete question"],"q":"Does help mean I must forget the person?","source_ids":["B30-P-15-N05-S1","B30-P-15-N05-S2"]},{"a":"No. It can clarify questions, but individual assessment requires a suitably qualified professional. Ancient analogies are not clinical criteria.","article_sections":["IV. Aristotle: a general account does not settle a particular case","V. Sirach: making room for the physician while retaining faith’s differences","IX. First contact can begin with an incomplete question"],"q":"Can a philosophical article decide which care I need?","source_ids":["B30-P-15-N05-S1","B30-P-15-N05-S2","B30-P-15-N05-S3"]}],"retrieval_limits":["Do not diagnose a reader or relative through duration, one feeling or a website checklist.","Do not require waiting for a diagnostic duration before contact; immediate safety requires urgent professional assistance.","Do not export UK numbers, access or confidentiality rules globally.","Transfer no ancient remedy, sin/illness association or mourning period into treatment; promise no result of prayer or care.","Do not make consultation betrayal of memory or compulsory growth; clinical profile review before publication NOT_RUN."],"revision":1,"schema_version":"uw.editorial_geo.v1","short_answer":"When coping is difficult, a condition worsens, or personal efforts are insufficient, individual professional assessment can be requested without a ready diagnosis. Diagnostic durations do not require delaying contact. Life at risk or inability to maintain safety calls for immediate local emergency assistance.","sources":[{"author":"Aristotle","checked_at":"2026-10-11","display":["Аристотель, Никомахова этика II.2, 4, 5; У. Д. Росс","Aristotle, Nicomachean Ethics II.2, 4, 5; W. D. Ross"],"id":"B30-P-15-N05-S1","limitations":"Ethics and medical analogy, not modern diagnosis, treatment or clinical grief moderation. No Greek original or whole-work reading claimed.","locator":"II.2 general/particular account and medicine/navigation; II.4 physician analogy; II.5 feelings/character. Quote II.2 particular-cases paragraph.","provenance":"Actual current browser primary reading before original P15N05 prose, 2026-10-11.","raw_source_import_allowed":false,"raw_source_vectorization_allowed":false,"read_scope":"Complete adopted II.2, II.4 and II.5 actually displayed/read before writing, plus W. D. Ross title credit; other book sections encountered but not adopted.","rights_note":"Six English words quoted. No full-text copying or ingestion licence inferred.","rights_status":"historical translation; worldwide clearance not asserted","source_type":"primary philosophical text in identified translation","title":"Nicomachean Ethics, Book II sections 2, 4 and 5","translator":"W. D. Ross","url":"https://classics.mit.edu/Aristotle/nicomachaen.2.ii.html","year":"Historical Ross translation; edition year not established from displayed page"},{"author":"Sirach, as received in the religious text","checked_at":"2026-10-11","display":["Сирах 38:1–14, контекст 15–23; King James Version","Sirach 38:1–14, contrasting context 15–23; King James Version"],"id":"B30-P-15-N05-S2","limitations":"Canonical status differs; not Ecclesiastes. No historical remedies, moral blame, brief mourning deadline or guaranteed prayer cure transferred into current guidance. No ancient original reading.","locator":"38:1–14 adopted; 15–23 contrasting context; epigraph opening nine-word clause of 38:1","provenance":"Complete current chapter primary reading before original prose, 2026-10-11.","raw_source_import_allowed":false,"raw_source_vectorization_allowed":false,"read_scope":"All 34 primary chapter verses actually displayed/read before drafting. 1–14 adopted; 15–23 critically noted, not accepted sin/illness blame or grief deadline; crafts 24–34 encountered, not used.","rights_note":"Nine English words quoted; no raw-source copying or ingestion permission inferred.","rights_status":"historical translation; jurisdictional status not globally cleared","source_type":"primary religious text in identified translation","title":"Ecclesiasticus / Sirach chapter 38, King James Version","translator":"King James Version","url":"https://www.kingjamesbibleonline.org/Ecclesiasticus-Chapter-38/","year":"Historical KJV; web edition date not established"},{"author":"NHS","checked_at":"2026-10-11","display":["NHS, горе после утраты; пересмотр 14 июля 2026","NHS, grief after loss; reviewed 14 July 2026"],"id":"B30-P-15-N05-S3","limitations":"UK education and pathways, not personalised triage or diagnosis. No transferred inevitable recovery assurance, universal deadline or treatment protocol.","locator":"Symptoms/stages; When and where to get medical help; prolonged grief information","provenance":"Current authoritative official page opened/read before original clinical guidance, 2026-10-11.","raw_source_import_allowed":false,"raw_source_vectorization_allowed":false,"read_scope":"Complete substantive page actually read before guidance: varied experiences, no fixed stage order, everyday support and grounds for medical help; reviewed-date observed.","rights_note":"No literal quotation. Narrow attributed clinical grounds only; no full copying or vectorization.","rights_status":"website rights notice applies; no unrestricted licence asserted","source_type":"official health information in original English","title":"Grief after bereavement or loss","translator":"Original English","url":"https://www.nhs.uk/mental-health/feelings-symptoms-behaviours/feelings-and-symptoms/grief-bereavement-loss/","year":"Actual displayed review 14 July 2026"},{"author":"American Psychiatric Association","checked_at":"2026-10-11","display":["APA, Prolonged Grief Disorder; врачебный пересмотр август 2025","APA, Prolonged Grief Disorder; physician review August 2025"],"id":"B30-P-15-N05-S4","limitations":"No self-diagnosis, full diagnostic criteria reproduction, prevalence/risk prediction, medication or modality selection. Diagnostic duration is not a prohibition on earlier help.","locator":"Substantive symptoms/diagnosis, social-cultural-religious context, treatment and physician-review section","provenance":"Current authoritative APA patient resource actually opened/read before guidance, 2026-10-11.","raw_source_import_allowed":false,"raw_source_vectorization_allowed":false,"read_scope":"Actual substantive lines 344–394 completely read before writing, including diagnosis-duration context, treatment overview and August 2025 physician credits; not the full DSM-5-TR.","rights_note":"No literal quotation; narrowly paraphrased classification boundaries, no complete copying.","rights_status":"website rights notice applies; no unrestricted licence asserted","source_type":"official psychiatric patient information in original English","title":"Prolonged Grief Disorder","translator":"Original English","url":"https://www.psychiatry.org/patients-families/prolonged-grief-disorder","year":"Displayed physician review August 2025"},{"author":"NHS","checked_at":"2026-10-11","display":["NHS, срочная помощь; фактический пересмотр 26 апреля 2023","NHS, urgent help; actual review 26 April 2023"],"id":"B30-P-15-N05-S5","limitations":"General safety boundary only, no individual risk assessment or new expert review claim; local numbers/resources not guessed; emergency-service details vary by locale.","locator":"Immediate professional advice/assessment; life at risk or inability to maintain safety","provenance":"Actual official page reading before safety guidance, 2026-10-11; freshness limitation explicit.","raw_source_import_allowed":false,"raw_source_vectorization_allowed":false,"read_scope":"Complete substantive urgent/emergency help page actually read; historical review date and expired due date observed. Local UK numbers encountered but not supplied to global readers.","rights_note":"No literal quotation; narrow safety ground, no full-page ingestion.","rights_status":"website rights notice applies; no unrestricted licence asserted","source_type":"official emergency health information in original English","title":"Where to get urgent help for mental health","translator":"Original English","url":"https://www.nhs.uk/nhs-services/mental-health-services/where-to-get-urgent-help-for-mental-health/","year":"Displayed review 26 April 2023; due 26 April 2026 already past"}]}